Ice cream is already a sweet and creamy treat, but some people take it to the next level with anything but ordinary toppings. While chocolate syrup and sprinkles are classics, there's a whole world of strange but surprisingly tasty combinations. These unusual toppings might initially sound weird, but many people swear by them.
Want to Save This Recipe?
Enter your email & I'll send it to your inbox. Plus, get great new recipes from me every week!
By submitting this form, you consent to receive emails from Blue's Best Life.
Some of these ideas are salty, some are spicy, and others are just unexpected. But together, they show how creative and fun desserts can be. Here are some wild and wonderful ice cream toppings that people enjoy, even if they initially sound odd.
Olive Oil and Sea Salt
Drizzling olive oil on ice cream might sound strange, but it creates a smooth and rich texture. The sea salt brings out the sweetness of the ice cream and adds a little crunch.
This combo works best with vanilla or chocolate flavors. People say it tastes fancy and reminds them of gourmet desserts. The olive oil also adds a fruity flavor that pairs well with the creaminess. Once you try it, you might never go back to plain toppings again.
Crushed Potato Chips
Potato chips on ice cream are the best way to combine salt and sweetness. The crunch of the chips adds texture, and the salt brings out the sugar in the ice cream. This is especially good with chocolate or caramel flavors.
Some people use flavored chips like BBQ, sour cream, and onion for a wild twist. It sounds wrong, but it tastes oh-so-right. The salty surprise might just become your new favorite topping.
Balsamic Glaze
Balsamic glaze is sweet, tangy, and syrupy; perfect for ice cream. It pairs well with strawberry or vanilla flavors. People like how it cuts through the sweetness with a tart kick.
It gives your dessert a fancy twist without needing many ingredients. A small drizzle can turn your bowl of ice cream into a restaurant-style treat. It might seem odd, but many food lovers rave about it.
Pickles
Yes, pickles on ice cream is a real thing! The sour crunch of the pickles contrasts with the creamy, sweet ice cream. This is a popular snack for some pregnant women, but many others enjoy it too.
Dill pickles work best, especially with vanilla ice cream. This snack surprises people and keeps them coming back for more. If you like weird food combos, this one is worth a try.
Cereal
When you add cereal to your ice cream, breakfast meets dessert. Fruity cereals, chocolatey cereals, or even cornflakes add a fun crunch. They also soak up the ice cream and get a little chewy in a good way.
Some people use cereal milk as the base flavor for their ice cream, too. It’s colorful, playful, and makes your bowl feel like childhood in a bite. Any kind of cereal can work, so try your favorite.
Wasabi Peas
Spicy and crunchy, wasabi peas bring heat to your sweet treat. It’s a topping for the brave and bold. The spice wakes up your taste buds and makes each bite exciting.
People who like spice say it adds depth to the dessert. It works well with vanilla or green tea ice cream. If you like mixing fire and ice, give it a go.
Hot Sauce
You read that right; hot sauce on ice cream. The heat from the sauce mixes with the cold cream for a wild flavor ride. Some people use fruity hot sauces like mango habanero for a tangy kick.
Others go bold with sriracha or Tabasco. It’s all about balance, so just use a few drops. Adventurous eaters love this sweet and spicy mix.
Soy Sauce
This one sounds like a joke, but it’s not. Soy sauce adds saltiness and umami to the flavor of the ice cream.
It goes surprisingly well with caramel or vanilla. Some say it reminds them of salted caramel. Just a dash will do the trick. Please don’t knock it until you try it.
Bacon Bits
Bacon makes everything better; even ice cream. The salty, crispy pieces add a smoky flavor that works great with maple or chocolate ice cream. Some people even drizzle maple syrup on top for a full breakfast vibe.
It’s a crunchy, savory topping that makes your dessert feel like a meal. You can use real bacon or bacon-flavored crumbles. Either way, it’s a bold choice that wins fans.
Popcorn
Popcorn brings a buttery crunch to any scoop. It’s light, airy, and fun to eat with ice cream. Some people like caramel popcorn for extra sweetness.
Others go for plain or salted for that movie-theater mix. It’s great for parties or movie nights at home. For a twist, try it with chocolate or strawberry ice cream.
Gummy Bears
Gummy bears aren’t that strange, but they’re unusual in texture. When they get cold, they turn extra chewy.
Some people love that challenge with each bite. They’re colorful, fun, and great for kids. The mix of fruity gummies with creamy ice cream is a flavor explosion. Just be careful not to hurt your teeth!
Chopped Jalapeños
Spicy jalapeños on ice cream? It’s more common than you think. The heat gives a surprise jolt that balances with the sweetness.
People say it’s refreshing in a strange way. Pickled jalapeños work best because they’re tangy too. If you like bold flavors, this combo delivers.
Blue Cheese Crumbles
This one’s for grown-up taste buds. Blue cheese on ice cream sounds wild, but it’s actually complex and interesting.
It pairs well with honey, fig, or berry flavors. The cheese adds salt, richness, and a bit of funk. It’s a choice for people who like bold, fancy food. Try it on a small scoop first; you might love it.
Pretzels
Pretzels bring crunch and salt, which goes great with chocolate or caramel ice cream. Some people crush them; others stick whole ones into the scoop. They add fun texture and flavor without being too weird.
Pretzels also soak up the melted ice cream just a bit. The result is a salty-sweet mix that feels just right. It's a safe but still unusual topping to try.
Avocado
Avocado is creamy and rich. It is sometimes blended into ice cream, but it can also be topped. When sliced thin or mashed, it adds a buttery taste that blends smoothly with sweet flavors.
People often pair it with lime or coconut ice cream. Some even drizzle honey on top for extra sweetness. It's healthy, colorful, and surprisingly smooth. If you like trying trendy foods, this one’s for you.
Leave a Reply