Everyone knows that going to New York City will involve grabbing a slice of true New York Style pizza. In fact, pizza availability is on every square block of Gotham. It is simple and balanced, without the boutique complications that stray away from the iconic classic. But what if you crave a slice, but are not in the Big Apple? This collection shares Yelp reviewers' top pizza spots across the country, with NY crusts as the must have. This time, it is NOT any way you slice it as it must be the iconic New York tradition.
Want to Save This Recipe?
Enter your email & I'll send it to your inbox. Plus, get great new recipes from me every week!
By submitting this form, you consent to receive emails from Blue's Best Life.
Outta Sight Pizza--San Francisco, CA
There is no need to travel from San Francisco to the Big Apple to experience the famous New York pizza. Outta Sight Pizza offers NY-style thin-crust pizza. With every bite, it's like walking on the streets of New York. Outta Sight Pizza's flavorful and crispy crust is perfect with the classic toppings.
Review: i normally DO NOT like pizza but i will definitely be coming back for outta sight pizza. one of their special ones, 'the pear' was so delicious - crust is so thin and not soggy, all the flavors melt together well and the people are great here. It's not cheap enough to consider it a good deal but i think worth the price
Learn more about Outta Sight Pizza here
Sapori Di 786 Degrees – Pasadena, CA
Discover the beautiful taste of handcrafted dough and wood-fired NY-style pizza at Sapori Di 786 Degrees, located in the heart of Pasadena, California. Customers love how their crust is soft and crispy on the outside, and the balanced flavors of sauce and cheese.
Review: Yum great pizza! We came here on a Friday at 3P and the pizza took longer than expected. He said it'd only take 20 min but jt ended up being closer to 40 min. Understandably there were a ton of orders and he did give us free drinks because of the wait so it was ok.
Ordered one of their most popular tikka masala pizza and the margherita pizza -- both were really good.
Learn more about Sapori Di 786 Degrees here
Home Slice Pizza – Austin, TX
Transport yourself to the Big Apple with Home Slice Pizza's authentic New York-style pizza with a twist of Texas. Its generous toppings and slices make it a hit and a spot in locals' and visitors' hearts, making it a must-try in Austin, Texas.
Review: So when there is pizza in the name of the restaurant, you would think to order pizza. But I went off-course and ordered the Italian sandwich. I'm so pleased I did. It was awesome. Home made sesame seed bun. It was listed under cold sandwiches but when it arrived the exterior of the bread was toasted and warm. The meats were piled well and the toppings were fresh. It was really good. I also had some pizza that was very good but the sandwich stole the show. 6" will satiate most people with 12" good for two. The decor was good with dim lights and that Italy feel. Bottles of wine lining the bar made me want a carafe. Only negative is they could use real wine glasses instead of water glasses but now I'm being too particular. House wine was fine. Service was good - we were well tended to. Double thumbs up.
Learn more about Home Slice Pizza here
Serious Pie--Seattle, WA
Who could say to a slice of New York-style pizza? Serious Pie is a pizzeria on the West Coast that will take you to the Big Apple. Premium toppings and thin crust crafted to perfection make their pizza a buzz in Seattle.
Review: Went on 04/24/2025,
From the moment we walked into Serious Pie Downtown, we were impressed. The atmosphere was vibrant and full of life, yet still cozy and inviting. Even though the place was busy, the staff were incredibly personable and attentive, making us feel welcomed and well taken care of.
We ordered the Yukon Gold Potato, Ferndale Farm mozzarella and the Roasted Oyster & Crimini Mushroom pizza with truffle cheese and wow, they were both out of this world! The crust was perfection crispy, chewy, and full of flavor. Each bite was a perfect balance of fresh, high-quality ingredients.
We also tried their lemonades, which were light, refreshing, and a great complement to the savory pizzas. The music added to the vibe, upbeat but not too loud, allowing for easy conversation. The restaurant was spotless, and despite the crowd, everything ran smoothly. What really stood out was how reasonably priced everything was, especially for the exceptional quality and experience. Serious Pie is more than just pizza, it's a full-on culinary treat in a relaxed, feel-good setting. We can't wait to return!
Learn more about Serious Pie here
Zaza’s Pizzeria--Chicago, IL
Although Chicago is famous for its deep dish, Zaza's Pizzeria in Windy City offers a NY-style pizza. Customers love its crispy yet foldable slices and fresh toppings. It's a paradise for pizza lovers.
Review: This is one of my new favorite Chicago pizzas! Zaza's lives up to the hype. The hot honey pepperoni is perfect in every way.
Cheese curds are also phenomenal. Crunchy and more like mozzarella stick bites.
Pizza came out quickly on a Saturday night. Can't wait to come back!
Zaza's is also BYOB
Learn more about Zaza’s Pizzeria here
Pizza Thief – Portland, OR
Pizza Thief's New York-style pizza has a unique twist, making it one of Portland's favorites. They have local cheese as one of their toppings and truffle oil, both perfect with crispy crust pizza. Pizza Thief is one of the must-try pizzerias in the Pacific Northwest.
Review: During a work trip to the NW Montgomery Park area, found a great pizza spot. Pizza Thief, as you walk into the building you are greeted by a very friend staff.
The interior is very causal and inviting, there is an attached walk way to an attached bar. To place your order, you line up and then queue to the main counter, to your left they have a large display case of the various pizza types, you can order them by slice or a whole pie. The menu board is easy to read, you really need to try the various dipping sauces, they have a small charge for them, my favorite the Ranch is amazing, enjoy the others.
I ordered the Kevin Pepperoni slice, I really love the small Pepperoni, its a nice large slice of pizza, it takes a few min to heat up your pizza, they will call your name once its ready. They offer a variety of drinks both alcoholic and regular drinks.
The pizza was amazing, very flavorful, cheesy and a nice crust, again the dipping sauces are a must. If you enjoy the outdoors, they have a nice covered area with bench style seating. It was very clean, bright and inviting business. I cannot wait to visit again.
Learn more about Pizza Thief here
Pie.Zaa – Asheville, NC
Locals and visitors who crave the Big Apple's style of pizza in Asheville usually go to their favorite pizzeria spot, Pie.ZAA, where you can try their classic hand-tossed crust and a very generous pizza serving. Combining local ingredients with traditional techniques makes a fantastic pizza that many love.
Review: The Real Deal - PieZaa Pizza Never Disappoints!
I've eaten at PieZaa Pizza many times now, and I can confidently say it's anything but "just reheated pizza." Anyone who claims otherwise clearly doesn't know great pizza when they taste it! The flavors are fresh, bold, and crafted with care every single time.
One of the standout features for me is the crust. That extra touch of butter and garlic takes it to a whole new level--it's absolutely superb. Whether I'm indulging in my go-to pepperoni or their incredible sausage pizza (seriously, don't miss this one!), every bite is a reminder of why I keep coming back.
PieZaa Pizza has mastered the art of pizza-making, and it shows in every detail--from the quality of the toppings to the warm and welcoming atmosphere. This is the kind of pizza that keeps you dreaming about your next visit.
If you haven't been here yet, do yourself a favor and give it a try. Trust me, this is the pizza you've been looking for.
Allday Pizza – Austin, TX
One of the pizzas that can compete with New York's in Austin, Texas, is Allday Pizza. Their crispy yet foldable slices are made with high-quality and fresh ingredients, from the crust to the toppings. At Allday Pizza, you can relax and chill, as they also have a cozy atmosphere matching their mouthwatering pizzas.
Review:Look, I haven't had all of the pizza in Austin... yet. But this is the best I've had so far. Fun fact: I have one sticker on my water bottle and it's an Allday sticker. I believe in this place. I found it by chance. I was driving with my windows down and I smelled Allday. I knew it'd be good just from th aroma.
It's counter service and connected to a wine spot.
On your first experience you'll want to get the sampler like we did. Afterwards you'll realize the stracciatella is the best slice they offer and you'll want to eat more of it til you're sick. Well... maybe don't do that.
The Caesar salad has no business being as good as it is. It's by far the best one I've ever had. I'm actually tempted to say it's one of best salads I've ever had.
The soft serve is decent. I haven't tried the olive oil cake yet, but it does look good.
Learn more about Allday Pizza here
The Nona's Slice House -- Safety Harbor, FL
Using fresh ingredients and traditional recipes, The Nona's Slice House offers a New York-style pizza in Safety Harbor, Florida. Its bold flavors and crispy crust make it stand out in town.
Review: Probably one of my favorite pizza spots in Safety Harbor. The Margherita pizza is my all time favorite, and I love the Olde World Style crust. The size of the pizzas are pretty large if you want to share.
I would recommend getting take out because seating is limited and parking gets full very quickly. Service is good and they're very accommodating, and I've never had issues ordering pizza from here.
Learn more about The Nona's Slice House here
Pizza Jeans – Atlanta, GA
One of the best New York-style pizzas in Atlanta, Georgia, is from Pizza Jeans. With its mouthwatering toppings, crispy thin crust, and relaxing atmosphere, Pizza Jean's pizza is a hit and famous to anyone craving the authentic slice of NY-style pizza in town.
Review: LOVE THIS SPOT! I recently found it in Ponce and we Loved it!! This Pepperoni and Vodka sauce slice was so great! I love how large their slices are! We got a full pie and had tons left over for the next day! I think they have lunch deals as well! Definitely try it next time youre at Ponce!
Leave a Reply